Colette Luke – Medill National Security Zone http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu A resource for covering national security issues Tue, 15 Mar 2016 22:20:28 +0000 en-US hourly 1 The Syrian conflict: What should America’s next move be? http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/blog/2013/06/17/the-syrian-conflict-what-should-americas-next-move-be/ Mon, 17 Jun 2013 19:35:31 +0000 http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/site/?p=15567 Continue reading ]]> WASHINGTON – With the death toll likely to be as high as 120,000 in the two-year Syrian conflict, some critics say the United States should start providing military assistance to curtail the fighting, which is destabilizing its neighboring countries and decreasing U.S. credibility and its stance on chemical weapons.

“The longer it goes on, the more people will die and the greater the chance of destabilization of Lebanon and Jordan, “ said David Schenker of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy and a former senior Defense Department official on Middle East issues in the Bush administration. “The bottom line is that this is a problem that won’t age well. “

In Jordan, there are close to 500,000 refugees and in Lebanon, the number is even higher. According to Schenker, Jordan will have an estimated 1 million refugees by the year’s end and the country’s current population is only about 6 and half million people. Schenker says that this will be a “huge burden” on the country.

As more refugees move into both bordering countries, the local people are competing with refugees for the scarce jobs. In Jordan, the refugees are driving up unemployment and rental prices as they stay in housing complexes. Additionally, the influx of refugees, particularly Sunni Syrians, is tilting the sectarian power-sharing balance of the Lebanese government.

Schenker says the U.S. should intervene militarily and “tip the balance” in favor of the rebels. He said some of the U.S. options include providing weapons to the vetted opposition, cratering runways so that the Assad government can’t use aircraft to bomb civilians, targeting strategic weapons depots and creating no fly zones. He does not believe it would be advisable to deploy American troops on Syrian soil.

Currently, the U.S. government is providing $60 million in nonlethal assistance to the Syrian Opposition Coalition. The money is being used to expand the delivery of basic goods and services and for administrative functions of security and communication.

This is in addition to the $50 million in nonlethal assistance to Syrian activists that has been used to “organize opposition efforts across the country and to amplify their message to Syrians and to the world through communications and broadcasting equipment”, according to the State Department.

However, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution agrees the nonlethal assistance is not enough.

“What we are providing is reasonable, but fairly minimal and not adequate, “ Michael O’Hanlon said, a Brookings fellow who specializes in American foreign policy who is also a visiting lecturer at Princeton University.

O’Hanlon said it’s important to come up with a plan that resembles the Bosnia model and to consider the questions of what happens after Assad has fallen and how to stabilize the country. He said a “smart plan” would involve the following: protecting the rights of the minority groups in Syria, providing weapons to the opposition, establishing a reasonable peace deal with the Assad government and possibly intervening with military force of no more than 20,000 American troops.

If the U.S. continues to stray away from providing weapons, this could affect U.S. credibility and its stance on chemical weapons portrayed to other countries, according to Schenker.

He said as the conflict persists, there is “danger of chemical leakage into the hands of the terrorists and Islamist militants.”

It has been reported that the Assad government in Syria has used chemical weapons against its own people.  Notwithstanding President Obama’s so-called “red line” on the use of these weapons of mass destruction in the conflict, the US has yet to intervene.

Schenker said US inaction in the face of these reports—and in opposition to the president’s warning to the Assad regime–sends a message not only to Syria, but to other countries in the region.

“It undermines US credibility in terms of the longstanding threat to use force to prevent Iran from attaining a nuclear weapon,” Schenker said.

]]>
Syrian refugees causing strain on Lebanon and Jordan http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/blog/2013/06/17/syrian-refugees-causing-strain-on-lebanon-and-jordan/ Mon, 17 Jun 2013 19:35:02 +0000 http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/site/?p=15561 Continue reading ]]> As conflict escalates in Syria, the number of refugees in Lebanon and Jordan continue to rise as well as displaced individuals inside Syria itself. More than 950,000 Syrians are registered as refugees or are awaiting registration in neighboring countries and 2.5 million are refugees within Syria itself, according to the State Department.

Currently, the U.S. spends $385 million in humanitarian assistance for people affected by continuing conflict.

The refugee conditions in Lebanon and Jordan are quite different. In Lebanon, most refugees live in homes and villages, but in Jordan, most refugees live in camps.

Having refugee camps allows Jordan to keep track of refugees coming in and, more importantly, to ensure that they are getting humanitarian aid.

In Jordan, there are close to 500,000 refugees and in Lebanon the number is even higher, according to Amal Mudallali, an expert on Syria and the Middle East at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.

The number of Syrians seeking refuge since the beginning of this year rose nearly 40 percent as the fighting has escalated.

As more Syrians move into Lebanon, Mudallali said this is putting strain on the economies of both countries. In the last two years, tension has been building between local residents and Syrian refugees as both are fighting for scarce jobs and resources.

In Lebanon, the situation is even more complicated because the political system is based on a sectarian power sharing formula and as more Sunni Syrians enter the country, the Christians and Shiites are getting more nervous. They are worried about a change in sectarian balance in the country.

In the last two years, the United Nations estimates that more than 70,000 Syrians have been killed since conflict began, according to a State Department report. The Syrian insurgency started after protests against the Assad government in March 2011. The protests grew nationwide and became part of Arab Spring, a larger Middle-Eastern movement to oust power through non-violent and violent demonstrations.

The Syrian Army was ordered to open fire on the demonstrators, which escalated the tension. It formed local groups, known as Syrian Opposition Coalition, that wants to overthrow the regime.

The U.S. currently supplies around $115 million in nonlethal support to the Syrian opposition to expand delivery of goods and services and for administrative functions of security and communication, according to the State Department.

Britain is supplying armored vehicles, body armor and communication supplies to the opposition, according to the BBC.

Mudallali said if the U.S. intervenes militarily in Syria it would “complicate an already complicated situation further.”

“The Syrian opposition is calling for arms that can change the balance of power on the ground,” Mudallali said. “They are frustrated that the U.S. has not accepted to do so.”

She said the Syrian opposition is correct for believing that the only way the Assad government will relinquish power and accept transition to a new government is when it realizes they have lost control of the country.

The United States and Russia have agreed to peace talks to find a political solution to the conflict in Syria.

United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay said in a statement early May that she was in support of these peace talks and that the brutal nature of this conflict makes international efforts to halt the bloodshed “imperative”.

]]>