Jin Wu – Medill National Security Zone http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu A resource for covering national security issues Tue, 15 Mar 2016 22:20:28 +0000 en-US hourly 1 Data collection brings more benefits than loss, experts say http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/blog/2015/08/11/data-collection-brings-more-benefits-than-loss-experts-say/ Tue, 11 Aug 2015 14:51:55 +0000 http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/site/?p=22886 Continue reading ]]> WASHINGTON – You’re probably one of the 91 percent of American adults who think they’ve lost control over how their personal information is collected and used by companies (according to a Pew Research study in early 2015). But big data collection brings benefits that outweigh the potential downsides, contended Ben Wittes, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, in a panel discussion at the Capital Visitor Center last Thursday.

Consumers’ concern about online privacy are at all-time high due to the emerging technologies – for instance, e-commerce and mobile devices– which collects a big chunk of consumer data, the Pew Research study says.

However, people who worry about “privacy eroding into the river and being gone forever,” added Wittes, ignore how those benefits actually increase privacy.

The rise of online sales has meant you can mail-order products that might be too embarrassing to buy in person, Wittes added. “Without looking at somebody in the eye, without confessing the interest in this subject, you get what you want.”

Because all e-books look the same on an e-reader, for instance, you can read Fifty Shades of Grey on your Kindle without shame—which may explain why the e-version of this book has outsold its printed version.

The value of the privacy of those purchases, Wittes argued, outweighs the value of the data given for them—like email, credit card numbers, browsing history, personal preferences, and location-based information.

Wittes suggested changing vocabulary that consumers use to describe the benefits they get with giving up some personal information. It’s not only “convenience,” he said, “it’s also privacy benefits.”

Joshua New, policy analyst at the Information Technology Innovation Foundation, said data collection also brings economic benefits to consumers.

He cited car insurance as an example. Instead of deciding your insurance premium based on broad factors – for instance, age, gender, neighborhood, drivers could use data to prove that they are cautious and don’t brake rapidly to get lower premiums even they are in the “high-risk section” based on traditional measurements, New said.

People who strive for online privacy should be aware that there is a cost to it. Adam Thierer, a senior research fellow at George Mason University, said it’s not impossible for people to protect their privacy if they don’t mind losing the benefits of giving up their data.

“Companies can offer paid options where user information won’t be collected,’ Thierer said. “But at the moment, I don’t think many people will pay for their privacy.”

A balance between consumer privacy and technology innovation is what the Federal Trade Commission is pursuing. Totally prohibiting data collection, which will create barriers for breakthrough innovations, is definitely not the solution.

“We should definitely limit the use of data,” said Federal Trade Commission member Maureen Ohlhausen, “but not limit the collection of data.”


Published in conjunction with PC World Logo

]]>
Is China a ‘lifesaver’ for US clean energy industry? http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/blog/2015/07/30/is-china-a-lifesaver-for-us-clean-energy-industry/ Thu, 30 Jul 2015 17:12:25 +0000 http://nationalsecurityzone.medill.northwestern.edu/site/?p=22866 Continue reading ]]> WASHINGTON – Chinese investments in renewable energy projects have reached record levels worldwide. And U.S. energy experts predict more money will pour into the U.S. clean energy sector in the near future, although the investments have lagged recently.

In 2014 alone, China saw more than $83 billion flow into renewable energy. That was up 39 percent from the previous year, and more than double of what U.S. invested, a United Nations Environment Programme report says.

The current state of Chinese investment in America’s green economy was a hot topic at a Wilson Center panel on Thursday in Washington.

Chinese investors have actually contributed less to clean energy projects in the United States in recent years, according to American Enterprise Institute, a Washington think tank.

However, the Chinese have been “lifesavers” for some projects over the past eight years they will be there in the future, said Melanie Hart, director of China policy at the Center for American Progress.

“U.S. clean energy started to take off right after the financial crisis. So when clean energy firms tried to get off the ground and seek financial support, it became really challenging,” Hart said at the panel.

When venture capital, hedge funds and state banks refused to lend easy money to those American companies due to the high risk of alternative energy technologies, Chinese banks and companies stepped in and “created lifelines of financing,” Hart added.

It’s still true even with the U.S. economy slowly recovering from the Great Recession. “Now the U.S. investors see the competitiveness of clean energy and they are bullish on this, it’s still hard for them to finance some breakthrough technologies,” Hart said. “But Chinese investors are still willing to support.”

The Wilson Center, a group with expertise in foreign policy and environmental issues, said data it aggregated show Chinese clean energy investment has created a modest 6,000 jobs in U.S. since 2006.

For instance, Goldwind Science and Technology Co., a wind turbine manufacturer based in Xinjiang Province, invested $200 million in 2010 in the Shady Oaks wind farm project in Lee County, Illinois, providing around 300 local jobs.

According to a report released by the Washington-based Center for American Progress, more than half of 65 U.S. energy projects currently funded by Chinese direct investments are clean energy – including wind, solar and electric vehicles.

To further assist the US to pursue a clean energy economy, more investment from China is critical, Hart emphasized.

Chinese private energy firms accounted for 70 percent of Chinese direct investment in the U.S. clean energy sector in 2013. But many were drawn back to China’s local markets to produce coal substitutes, said Derek Scissors, resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. But he predicts the money will come back when China “overshoots” its alternative energy production capacity domestically.

China’s low investment in U.S. clean energy “will change because China is shifting its energy mix at home and they are going to build up too much capacity in alternative energy, like they always do,” Scissors said. “They will export the capacity overseas then. At that time, we will see more investments here on clean energy.”

“It is obvious to happen,” he said. “The question is just when.”

]]>